From Autonomies
Tomás Ibáñez (18th of October 2026)
from Redes Libertarias 20/10/2026
The intense events of 17 October, with their long list of violent clashes in many French cities, show that France could not be an exception. Just as has happened in recent years in many regions of the world – from the Americas to South-East Asia, via several European countries – we have witnessed on this occasion an outburst of discontent that had been slowly building up, with hundreds of thousands of people taking to the streets and showing a determination capable of withstanding even the most forceful police crackdowns. As in so many other countries, the people who fuelled the demonstrations on this 17th of October did not do so by obeying slogans issued by large organisations, but primarily through social media, through everyday conversations circulating within the social fabric of neighbourhoods and workplaces, and also in response to calls from small organisations, without any centralising body acting as an intermediary between them.
It turns out that the absence of structures to organise and direct the demonstrations lends them a certain air of self-organisation, leaving decisions to those directly involved in the protests, spurring their creativity, and making them the protagonists of the actions undertaken. It is clear that they are not fighting to advance some supposed revolutionary project. However, they are engaging in practices that are revolutionary in the here and now because, by confronting the tremendous force of the system that their mobilisation is challenging, they are creating a climate of dissent whose short- and medium-term consequences are difficult to predict.
The international proliferation of events such as those of the 17th of October in France bears witness to the validity of those viewpoints which maintain that wherever domination tightens its grip, resistance inevitably emerges and revolt breaks out. Such views therefore predict that large-scale mobilisations will erupt sporadically, and with an apparently spontaneous character, in places where local circumstances of oppression ignite the sparks of insurrection, in some cases leading to a ripple effect in other places, but without these outbursts being the product of grand emancipatory narratives.
As is customary when the roar of discontent takes to the streets, the media prioritise the most spectacular images, which are usually those of pitched battles, fires and attacks on objects that in some way symbolise the instruments of oppression. This, combined with the comments of those in power and defenders of the established order, provokes fear and rejection amongst a large section of the population. And, as is also customary, the political parties and groups that more or less explicitly support the uprisings are quick to express their condemnation of actions labelled “violent”, when they do not go so far as to attribute them to deliberate provocations. This is what Mélenchon, for example, the leader of the party situated to the left of the Socialist Party and aligned with the Frente Amplio operating on this side of the Pyrenees, has done. If such actions occur during the protests taking place ahead of the 29 November elections, we will need to keep a close eye on how the leadership of the Frente Amplio reacts, as well as the organisations backing these strikes and protests.
It has been several years now since the peak of the “Yellow Vests” movement came to an end, but that symbol has made its mark – without quite turning them yellow – on demonstrations in various cities, and this highlights one of the most valuable outcomes of intense collective struggles: they act as a catalyst for raising awareness and, in a matter of days, forge activists who will remain so until their dying breath. Creating long-lasting, defiant and subversive subjectivities is the precious outcome of radical collective struggles, whatever their outcome may be; not to rejoice in the ferocity of the clashes and the brilliance of the flames, but to denounce them, is to do a disservice to the creation of that flow of forces of resistance to the established system that is born of the struggle.
Comments
Some notable bullshit
disorder (not verified) Thu, 10/29/2026 - 01:02
Ibáñez is often rather careful. But here his post-anarchists mantra is simply contrary to what happened, and what happened is an interesting lesson for future revolts.
"The international proliferation of events such as those of the 17th of October in France bears witness to the validity of those viewpoints which maintain that wherever domination tightens its grip, resistance inevitably emerges and revolt breaks out. Such views therefore predict that large-scale mobilisations will erupt sporadically, and with an apparently spontaneous character, in places where local circumstances of oppression ignite the sparks of insurrection, in some cases leading to a ripple effect in other places, but without these outbursts being the product of grand emancipatory narratives."
In fact, resistance doesn't "inevitably" emerge wherever domination tightens its grip. In most cases it doesn't. Then why did the revolt break out this time? It's because the high school students, with their inventiveness in word and in deed, have been building a "grand emancipatory narrative" for one month now. It's not a grand narrative of some bearded elderly or dead man, but it is a grand narrative of democracy opposed to the current government, to the emerging forms of fascism, to State violence; it is a narrative that reclaims basic social and economical rights (related to housing and to education); it also reclaims the playful liberation of time, among others. I'm mentioning only a few of the things that are constantly written on the improvised banners, graffiti, posters, etc. Now, these elements do not make up a unified theory (for better or for worse). But they do give a general tone that determines concrete actions, like that attack on the main fascist media outlet, CNews, in the morning of October 17th.
All of the things mentioned above have their limits. So does the almost uncontested faith in the main Radical Left party, La France insoumise. But it is sheer ideological rambling to neglect what the movement actually thinks, says and does. What's unique this time is that it does think and it does speak. Nobody knows how it will evolve. But those first steps in autonomy are something unseen since a very long time in France.
”a grand narrative of…
Bugs Bunny (not verified) Thu, 10/29/2026 - 10:45
In reply to Some notable bullshit by disorder (not verified)
”a grand narrative of democracy opposed to the current government, to the emerging forms of fascism, to State violence; it is a narrative that reclaims basic social and economical rights (related to housing and to education)”
“Generally speaking, the goals of today’s leftists are NOT in conflict with the accepted morality. On the contrary, the left takes an accepted moral principle, adopts it as its own, and then accuses mainstream society of violating that principle.” Still laser accurate in the big 2026, pew pew. 2 years of student protests in Serbia just ended to arrive at poll booth, same as the Gen Z revolts, and it will be no different here. It can never be different.
Add new comment