weird wierd

Following up on last week's TOTW, I wanted to discuss the relationship between language, anarchism, and the limitations of practicality. 

In a recent Food Not Bombs meeting when someone said our work was revolutionary, I countered what seemed self-evident to me, "Well, feeding poor folks isn't really revolutionary." I didn't mean we ought not to do it, but the other person seemed to believe so, "So, you think we shouldn't be doing it?" For my view on FnB, the work isn't revolutionary, but is still good. This is especially true when the work is focused less on the "mutual" and more on the "aid" (a larger conversation that can't take place here), mirroring more charity work than the radical reciprocal style proposed by FnB-ists.

I am sure you, dear reader, have had similar interactions. A simple criticism or acknowledging a limitation becomes an accused dismissal.

On a larger scale, I connect this to Ukraine and anarchist involvement in the state's war effort. It is often responded in some way that anarchist involvement is "practical" or the need is "immediate." I've shifted in my own opinion from hardline opposition to involvement to a softer one, where anarchists may join for practical or immediate needs, but the act itself is not anarchistic. We make decisions every day as anarchists, ones that may sadly be anti-anarchist, but also simply not anarchist. It doesn't mean those latter decisions are "bad" or "good" but we shouldn't dupe ourselves, muddy the waters, reducing anarchism to something that it isn't. 

  1. What are the reasons people prefer to focus on the so-called practical work or the theory/harder conversations? The line between the two need not exist, but seemingly for some, it does.
    2. Why are some folks disposed to strong reactions to criticism of the work?
    3. What is the line between being an-anarchist-doing-something and a task being actually anarchistic?

     

Comments

Billy (not verified) Sun, 10/11/2026 - 08:11

What is the obsession with being and identity? What's the point.

I would prescribe a dose of dis-identity politics to a lot of people.

What is more important than "being" an identity or trying to pack actions and items into an identity category to uphold a meme in this era of semantic apocalypse?

Trying to reduce the actions of those far away to the category of anarchist or not anarchist so we can try to batten down the definition of a label?

None of that is important. Everything, literally everything else is more important.

Learning electronics, learning first aid, growing food, learning computers, learning to hack, learning prepping and survivalism, fixing old things, creating real sources of news and networks.

If people were sitting down doing analysis of things like food production and what future tech will allow us to get off grid and make stuff at home for cheap then people would be more interested.

Most theory isn't even rooted in reality. It's idealism, closer to performance art and a kind of mystical vibe based wish fulfillment that our postures will contain symbolic resonances and cause some magical shift in the worlds consciousness.

That's all a bit too 60s for me.

Maybe instead of theory what we need is something more like logistical descriptions.

You know what would be so much more interesting to me personally? A detailed description of how people actually created that food drive. Right down to "so we cooked this for this cheap and we got these chairs from here" etc etc

More useful!

When I look in the mirror I don't see an identity. There isn't an identity hashtag over my life.

When I have been in situations were others have helped me survive and I have helped others it wasn't because of some decision to be an ideology.

In reality you move and work and make things up as you go along. We just try to compete for our memes to label and author events after the fact.

Trying to rigidly define a category of what action is this and what is that label is a kind of death.

The people I hate are the ones that go around saying "ah ha! You can't do that! You're not an anarchist if you do x!". Good. I don't even want to fall into a label then.

We got to get moving and stealing literally every single bit of information we can. Decommodify and circulate everything, from the techniques to building a house to cheap recipes to new networks to opsec to literally everything.

And we got to do this fast before AI destroys even more of the internet, poverty and closed libraries destroy even more books and smaller totally hacked devices destroy our ability to share and store files.

We're gonna end up in a place where everything that is free today is deleted, lost, then sold back to us as commodities.

In this world, people are desperate for identity and any validation of being X from others. But that is a kind of trap. Doing is always what matters and you can only be together when you do things together.

Experience teaches people but today most of us are so alone and isolated. The only way to learn is by doing and in this world when you can't even find other people with the time to teach you something irl then good guides what images texts and videos can at least be copied.

Tang Ping Moth… (not verified) Sun, 10/11/2026 - 09:28

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

They want to be commodified though. They want to buy their little trans flags (made in China) along with their little anarchy books (sold by Amazon) and all the constituent uniform, regalia, signifiers and sigils and they’re deathly afraid that their supreme identity, the CONSUMER, will one day be denied to them.

The people prepared will not be quote ANARCHISTS(TM), probably called cranks and shit, actually nameless and sane, and will be doing interesting work in the shadows on the periphery. Cool.

anonymous (not verified) Sun, 10/11/2026 - 20:19

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

not everything has to be about a thing, but you can't expect a website named after a thing not be about a thing. and you come here trying to make it not about the thing, you must have your own thing you want to make this thing about. sure, there's lots of other things and people are doing other things in particular and in specific; but what do those things have to do with this thing in particular? that's the topic of the week. they pick a thing and make it a thing that has to do with the thing the website's about. i guess you're just not about the thing, but about other things you listed.

Tang Ping Moth… (not verified) Mon, 10/12/2026 - 05:15

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

“If god existed, it would be necessary to abolish him”, yet perish the thought of someone abolishing the decrepit god of anarchism. Heathens in any age are always feared, because they are the most radical and they are correct.

anonymous (not verified) Mon, 10/12/2026 - 13:08

In reply to by Tang Ping Moth… (not verified)

Jesus was the OG giga-heathen, not the persecutor. Sorry, but that's true. Flatly.

Read the stuff from Girard about the Scapegoat figure in "Dionysus and the Crucified". Heathens are the scapegoats, yes, but society keeps creating them. Nowadays they're the homeless crackpots, and the "criminals" of course, both vilified and managed by the so-called Working Class.

Tang Ping Moth… (not verified) Mon, 10/12/2026 - 15:47

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

Jesus was a real motherfucker, I never said otherwise. The point is all things must be overthrown, even Proudhon’s bastard failsons, this is literally anarchism. One day someone more radical will topple me and I won’t cry like a puss about it.

Homeless and criminals can be cunts just like the working dead but that’s for another time. Sell your cloak, buy a sword, judge everyone.

anonymous (not verified) Mon, 10/12/2026 - 18:49

In reply to by Tang Ping Moth… (not verified)

"One day someone more radical will topple me and I won’t cry like a puss about it."

this makes no sense. so one day you're going to be sitting on your throne, choosing to scroll anews instead of wiping, and then some rando is going appear out of nowhere and topple you saying "I AM QUANTITY OF RADICALITY GREATER THAN YOU!"

anonymous (not verified) Sat, 10/17/2026 - 21:21

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

I agree. I haven't called myself an anarchist in a very long time for the same reasons. As for the ai bullshit I'm not worried. It's just a tool. We can take and use it for our own purposes we just have to learn and adapt. Our brains can still do things no machine can.

anonymous (not verified) Sun, 10/11/2026 - 09:04

If I can't practice, I can't practice. If I'm at a bookfair, I'm distroing. I mean, simple as that. It ain't about that. It's—it's not about that at all. You know what I'm saying? I mean, but it's—it's—it's easy to talk about, it's easy to talk about sum it up when you just talk about practical anarchy. We're sitting here, and I'm supposed to be an anarchist that practices, and we in here talking about practice. I mean, listen, we're talking about practice. Not a game! Not a game! Not a game! We talking about practice. Not a game; not a—not a—not the game that I go out there and—and die for and play every game like it's my last, not the game, we're talking about practice, man. I mean, how silly is that? We're talking about practice. YOU THINK THIS IS A MF'ING GAME!!!? I know I'm supposed to be on ANews commenting, I know I'm supposed to lead by example, I know that. And I'm not—I'm not shoving it aside like, you know, it means so much. I know it's important. I do. I honestly do. But we're talking about practice. What are we talking about? Practice? We talking 'bout practice. We're talk— We're talking about practice! We're talking about practice... We ain't talking about the game! We're talking about practice, man! When you come into the comments arena, and you see me play, you see me play, don't you? YOU THINK THIS IS A GAME?!!!

anonymous (not verified) Sun, 10/11/2026 - 17:00

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

love the Iverson rant. though isn't it something that, for trivial things like basketball, the game is the real thing, but for non-trivial things the practice is the real. think practicing herbalism or practicing midwifery or practicing meditation.

Le Way Sun, 10/11/2026 - 23:57

Zen without the frills will bring you closer to your authentic self,,,No schedules, ideologies, State, fashion culture, just your raw spontaneous Me in the Now,,,identity evaporates and emotion has more room to circulate.

anonymous (not verified) Mon, 10/12/2026 - 05:04

what’s a line? obviously there’s a distinction to be drawn between making soup and reading a book.

i agree with billy that a lot of anarchist “theory” is just blab - which brings me to an answer to #2. there is no consensed upon political curriculum (although there a seem to be a million “anarchy 101 explainers/faqs” providing rhetorical soundbites for the debate-prone). thus the judgement of people and their actions falls back on our common context supplied by capitalism, the modern (compatible) left and its mantra that “the personal is political”. if you are doing or believing something i disagree with it’s either because you are ignorant or just a bad person. and we all know how easy, and with how many reasons, it is to reach for the latter. after all there is no actual body of anarchist theory to draw on; or rather there is a wide and diffuse body of texts that we are all expected to simply draw on as we each please. ( individualism is the funniest anarchist tendency to me considering how closely it mirrors what we’re already living)

an anarchism of slogans and ideals is not automatically edified by joining it to an anarchism of serving soup (anymore than for left groups who try the same). what is “practical” anyway? i guess this is what #3 is getting at and i don’t really have an answer to that. i want you (the collective)to answer though, what is practical about joining or supporting a state military (like to avoid jail?) and how does anarchists doing that fit #3 in your opinion?

Tang Ping Moth… (not verified) Mon, 10/12/2026 - 16:08

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

Go to the shops or your city centre and tell me these people have will to power. They can barely power their heads up from their phones to look where they’re fucking going. Individuals ain’t individualism.

Marxism never had an overarching body of practical theory, and the state capitalist ‘variants’ even less and it didn’t stop them. Considering the nosediving reading rates, think school is out anyway.

Billy (not verified) Mon, 10/12/2026 - 17:48

In reply to by Tang Ping Moth… (not verified)

Those of us who adore to read (reference) are the real keepers of the lost flame.

Just in case anyone thinks it's some sort of boomer exaggeration it's not.

Talk to a teacher or those who have kids. The new gen is post literate. They can't do it. Screens have ruined them. The rich kids though, they have social spaces and are kept off screen.

What people want is audiobooks. YouTube videos. If your writing is not in that format it's kinda doomed.

There is a wave of almost feral desocialisation and psychosis and the breakdown of meaning and shared linguistics occuring. What is replacing language is a kind of automatism. Berardi manages to understand this well.

It's going to get very ugly.

I think I see it more because I'm a hick and where I'm from it was still kind of the 1950s in a lot of ways until recently.

I see it here with the awful rise in addiction but also a new kind of dividuated, anonymous and isolated behaviour in public spaces. People don't talk to strangers here anymore on the street. Now people sort of exist in isolated shells in which they have psychotic episodes and it doesn't appear they have any clear understanding others could intrude, and noone does. It's like, as Berardi almost says, there's been a kind of desynchronization of the social body.

People aren't even being connected by language, they're alone or they are mediated by screens and hashtags and labels and only swarm together around those, or to repeat them.

In these conditions any kind of small group is hard to build and maintain.

Bookstores are having a small revival in some places but dying overall. But I'm not sure many people can even handle a book. Sitting in silence reading a page that doesn't swipe...

You already see people who can't think and can't understand information unless it's hashtagged into a ingroup/outgroup label.

It's very strange what's happening.

I ramble about it because I don't fully understand it.

These are new conditions... I'm not sure we have a great theory about them or what to do in them.

It does feel like almost everything is disappearing into a digital void.

A great emptiness.

I go back to Baudrillard a lot now.

If you can build any irl relationships these days you're doing well. It's so hard. Sad AF sometimes.

anonymous (not verified) Tue, 10/13/2026 - 10:15

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

I'm still seeing a lot of kids in small gangs hanging out. But gangs are their own bubbles. Marxists tend to see them as a sign of social health, and obvs "Revolutionary Potential" (lol), but their formation is more part of the problem than the solution. Same for affinity groups" that are much worse due to being politicized, therefore even more isolated if not polarized from the rest of people.

The close(d) group formation is a continuation of the family bond in a different form. Both agglomerates are exclusive; that's the problem.

The other issue is that, yes, many of these groups are structured based on corporate social media as their entry and outlet. There was something healthier with groups forming out of video games -and even Pokemon Go's!- but here the social media is working as a partial or full smokescreen filter between the and the Outside world. And yes it's very dangerous, unless some cognitive dissonance can be created in some way. Think of Instagram hipsters for instance.

But some people grow out of this psychosis. And I'm seeing a lot of older Alpha kids who're folding back to a '90s kid mentality/conduct these days. There is a level of tech disenchantment happening but it might need to be further sustained & validated with conflicting stimulation of affects. What someone like Berardi and even Baudrillard have overlooked is D & G's Fredian/Reichian conclusion about the psychology of affect...

Books and book stores are still a thing btw. There's also a fraction of youngster reading books, as their parents and sometimes primary schools got them hooked up on it at early age. At the bottom line, the kids's problems are due to the adults' failings. Including anarchist adults.

Billy (not verified) Tue, 10/13/2026 - 12:40

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

Good for them.

It's easy to forget that adaptation is the only way forward.

Oh I don't care too much about Dolce and Gabanna. Nomad war machine? That's just ISIS bro.

There's a hundred thousand rich white dorks getting bodied without organs. I'll leave it to them.

You know the amount of commies that want to be in gangs because they can't handle their own individuation and long to become cognitively disabled in mob psychosis... They never get over jr. They're always the dorks that would be bullied out of any real gang.

I think it's healthy to schizo about this though. Alienation and digital disconnection does sever our herd instincts sometimes.

All we can do is ride the lighting.

Work learn and skill up.

But man is it getting cold and brutal out there now. I don't even use my headphones. When the survivalists talk about situational awareness they have a point. I'm big on personal security now.

UKG and IG now advises us to prep. Candles and food. Trump has sided with Putin against Ukraine. Harsh times are coming for old Europe.

This is why I say, realism and skilling up will serve us today better than idealism and 1960s imagination and sloganeering.

We got to get more logistical, more skilled, more survivalist imo. There is such a thing as too many poets and polemicists and scoldy moralists and not enough engineers, first aid training, cooks and builders.

Billy (not verified) Wed, 10/14/2026 - 14:39

In reply to by op (not verified)

All I'm trying to say is online space prioritizes identity and hashtagging and reducing information to identity itself. It's not a space in which people ask how to do things very often, it's a space in which people ask how to be something. How to be an indentity, then demand rules for it.

We should focus on practical things. How to actually do things. I mean this in the most literal way possible.

The doing is what creates real connections and that is what creates a network and if you want, an identity.

Most of everything else is about as serious as people putting labels to describe themselves in their twitter bios.

Billy (not verified) Tue, 10/13/2026 - 11:32

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

If I was living somewhere and had no way to flee, or refused to flee and abandon what little I had, or refused to flee because I refused to not fight fascist invaders and didn't want to abandon those around me - then joining a state military is to me acceptable.

If I'm fighting anyway then that might be the right decision to make.

At no point does this mean I expect that state military not to do what state militaries do. At no point does that mean I think I'm gonna trust it entirely. At no point does that mean I think I'm going to get anything other than at best a liberal society if it wins.

Like everything in life it's context specific.

The previous debates we had about this on here were intense and some people from that region contributed things that showed the true complexity of it all.

For me personally I'm not going to let any ideological term dictate what I can or can't do, including anarchism, which is guess what imo, the truly anarchist attitude.

Does this mean helping a state win is a path to anarchy? No. But I mean hell who knows what will happen. We all live within the shadows of overlapping states anyway.

anonymous (not verified) Thu, 10/15/2026 - 11:01

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

so fascists are ok as long as they are “defending” not “invading”? are you really going to tell me that azov and other far right groups that have been integrated into the ukrainian state are in no way fascist? we’ve even seen that some of the anarchists that joined up turned out to embrace the far right. or let me guess, everything ukrainian soldiers do is justified because russia is trying to “genocide” them?

“nationalism is acceptable because it can be anti-fascist” is a rationale that demonstrates the use of the fascist bogeyman to support the deeper structure of the bourgeois state, which toggles back and forth between “more democratic” and “more fascist” as needed.

people who are constantly warning about an imminent apocalyptic threat and a dystopian future, regardless what they claim to advocate, are cheerleaders for the present state of things who are perennially confused about what they are against

Billy (not verified) Thu, 10/15/2026 - 13:40

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

Here we go again for fuck sake.

I never said any of those things.

You can say I said those things, over and over again.

I don't know what it means that fascists are "ok". I guess if my country was being invaded by them, and there was a small fascist unit in the army defending against them, I could understand that they're both fighting each other and make sure I survive.

So no, I probably wouldn't do what the invading fascists wanted.

Have you ever been attacked? You tend to not punch the person who isn't trying to punch you and focus on defending against the ones that are at risk of killing you, breaking a limb or a bone, or giving you brain damage.

What the fuck do you want Ukrainians to do. Oh right, die or flee and let Russian murder and take over everything.

anonymous (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 16:23

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

“what do you want (x nationality) to do?!” i am the president of a nation so this is a very apt question for me. on the other hand i am also an anarchist so i mainly think about what i want to tell other people to do.

roll over and die… hm, you didn’t say russia is doing genocide? i guess you should ask the same question every time a cop shoots someone, because the rationale is always that they were in fear for their lives. hey what did you want the people in donbass to do in 2014. roll over and die? see how that works?

Billy (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 17:41

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

I don't follow you here at all man, sorry.

You can explain it again if you want.

If you're talking about cops in the USA/Canada shooting people, which I'm well aware they do, that's a separate issue. I don't think it ties in but if you wanna explain it go ahead

Billy (not verified) Thu, 10/15/2026 - 14:15

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

Also, let me make one more reply to this.

I am not in Ukraine and I have **zero** interest in telling them what to do.

All I did was answer a hypothetical.

The idea I would be interested in revoking their anarchy card or telling them I who am not facing the murderous onslaught they are facing should get to decide if they are or are not anarchist is obscene to me.

All I did was try to answer a very complex ethical question with the answer that I as an individual imagining myself in their situation would do.

I'm so not interested in preaching to them or labelling them.

But I am not going to play games and insult them or abandon my solidarity with anyone facing what they are facing.

That's all.

And I have read everything on this site in recent months about this. Read the book of interviews about this, listened to the deserters and the others.

Nobody should care what I think. All I'm doing is trying to understand the reality of this war which Putin aims to extend further into Europe.

My opinion is that we should **not** derelict our duty to understand this war. This war is telling us a lot about the future. There are not just novel forms of technological violence happening there but novel forms of politics in response to them.

We have a lot to learn from this. We owe it to ourselves and those who come after us to adapt our thinking and politics and strategies to this. Putin will keep going if he is not stopped.

Giggity (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 09:25

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

“Putin will keep going if he’s not stopped!!!”/ the war has degenerated after several years into a WW1 slogfest absolutely kiboshing even the daydream of European conquest. Don’t quit your day job Billy.

Billy (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 15:21

In reply to by Giggity (not verified)

If you paid proper attention to what's happening in Europe, which those of us who live here do, you'd know what's happening.

He doesn't intend to stop. He could open up a new front. He's created a war economy.

They do cyber and infrastructure attacks and assassinations and internet ops all over Europe for fuck sake.

When Ukraine hit the Yandex server the bots and support for far right parties dried up a lot.

You Americans who understand nothing of Europe and believe it is 20th century nazi Vs commie forever with bad libs who are really Nazis need to shut the fuck up for once.

Bombsaway (not verified) Thu, 10/15/2026 - 21:36

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

The post-Soviet Eastern bloc countries have all been littered with fascists since the 90s. Why is there so much focus on Azov? As if Russia doesn’t have fascists and Russian wasn’t supporting the growth of Fascism in the West.? The American MAGA movement and Alt-right, the AFD in Germany, the Brexit… they were all assisted in growing by Russian bots. Russians helped the feascists who want to kill you grow. Get outta my face with this campism crap. So far 4 out of 9 Russian data centers have been bombed. I hope the rest of them get bombed too.

anticampist (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 08:52

In reply to by Bombsaway (not verified)

Russia has fascists alright, some of whom, like White Rex, are fighting for Ukraine!

https://kanaldim.tv/ru/vesy-sudby-v-muzee-vojny-otkryli-vystavku-o-ross…

And then you have White Rex's good buddy Rundo who's been inspiring the Active Clubs in America and Canada based on his experience with Ukraine's fascist movement.

https://time.com/5926750/azov-far-right-movement-facebook/

I guess we here in North America should just roll over a die when those fascists attack us tho. Wouldn't want to be called a tankie by someone licking the boots of NATO and the pogromist OUN.

anonymous (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 09:58

In reply to by anticampist (not verified)

White Rex is only on the side of the war, regardless of camps. Same for some other "misanthropic" divisions, styled after the worst 4channer tendencies.

Anarchists must understand the principle of Winner Plays Both Sides before it's too late. Capitalists conservative state leaders do. Even some neofascist scumfucks do. So why still taking sides like gullible cannon fodder?

Enough poors have died for billionaire scum already.

anonymous (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 16:30

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

sigh, there are some very impassioned campists who spend a lot of time doing pro-ukraine posting here. i don’t think this reflects where people are at general. i could be wrong. but just look at how much more comments happen when ukraine comes up versus most other posts

Billy (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 17:30

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

I don't think you're wrong. I just think this is easy for those of us who don't live in Ukraine to say.

In a war like this you don't get the luxury of idealism unfortunately. If Ukraine falls, Putin will keep going.

So he's going to do that. He may very well launch a regular rather than hybrid attack against another European country soon.

So if everyone fled then it wouldn't stop him.

Do I want this to be true? No. But it is.

A lot of people have decided they refuse to believe he will keep attacking. They've decided this because it wraps it all up neatly and they can just purity signal against those in Ukraine.

There were those in Ukraine who thought he would never invade until he did.

I don't think the rest of us in Europe who have our eyes open have the luxury of not paying close attention to this.

I completely agree with you on the need to understand winner plays both sides btw.

Billy (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 10:28

In reply to by anticampist (not verified)

Also

I've seen those Active Club neonazi stickers where I live too.

They're all over Europe.

Guess where they originated. The USA. Where this guy is from.

When Putin invades another EU country people like him will be calling ALL of us liberal EU NATO nazis.

The Euro tankies already do this. They sit on Twitter smirking that Estonia is just fascist so it's ok really if Putin invades it and murders people there. They're Estonian. So they're all fascists. And they're not tankies so they must be.

Most Americans have an understanding of Europe about as sophisticated as Star Wars. There is Commies and Nazis and every one of us wants to secretly be one or the other. There's nothing else and noone in between or different or who rejects both those things. Every country here is secretly one or the other. There aren't people that got occupied by both and resisted and hate and fought off both.

More of us will have to face what Ukrainians are facing and our tankarchist friends in the US won't. They're safe in the belly of the great satan which nobody is land invading anytime soon.

The euro tankies I see on twitter will just sell their assets and flee, considering how rich some of them are.

anticampist (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 16:45

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

I like how you say "guess where" as if I didn't know where Rundo was from, as if where he's from wasn't part of my point in the first place. He's from America, gone to Ukraine and got inspired and come back and inspired the fascist movement in America and Canada (which are two different countries, as you're seemingly unaware), that's part of the point. Go on and keep bad-jacketing people for not talking about the Wagner Group when it's fascists in Ukraine, including the Russian fascists in Ukraine, who are inspiring the fascists on this continent more than the Wagner Group or other Russian fascists. I'm sure you'll scare someone into supporting your camp and its neo-nazis if you keep at it! Canada and America have been training and arming the fascists in Ukraine, not Russia, but pay no mind, we'll sacrifice ourselves over here so you can be safe over there. Hopefully Israel keeps up with the arms support to NATO in Germany and Latvia, etc. too. Anarchism is when your camp has more guns and you liberwash the fascists in your camp by doing a whataboutism over fascists in Russia. I like how you cry about people over here not caring about the supposed Russian invasion you're facing over there when you're openly saying you don't give a shit about people here. Good way to get solidarity. Liberal anarchism really not sending their strongest e-soldiers here.

Billy (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 17:11

In reply to by anticampist (not verified)

Guess you can just keep making up things I didn't say in post after post.

The sheer fucking gall to lie and claim I said I 'dont care about people in the USA Canada'.

You're not facing invasion. You'll never face that.

You also have easy access to guns.

You have your own problems but my god the fucking narcissism of comparing YOUR situation to Ukraine or any of the countries in Europe facing invasion...

Thanks for doing all the hard work you do calling everyone a liberal and a nazi.

You'll never face the death and danger and existential threat and ethical dillemas that Ukrainians face trying to survive.

But you WILL sneer at them and call them and everyone else liberal Nazis. Over and over and over again.

This doesn't cut it man.

Go do something better with your time because this isn't it.

anticampist (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 20:50

In reply to by Billy (not verified)

"You're not facing invasion. You'll never face that."

Might want to crack open the old history book, Billy. How do you think countries like Canada and America came to be? Here's a hint, invasion. Not sure why anyone should listen to you about Europe when you're this monumentally ignorant about basic facts of history. Even if Canada and America weren't themselves the products of invasion, we'd over here would still have more of an ability and responsibility to oppose their imperialism (including their involvement in NATO) than we do that of Russia's. The Russian invasion of North America ended quite a while ago (though it still shapes "our" borders). The Euro/Yank/Canuck invasions have yet to end. Must be blissful to be as clueless as you are.

Billy (not verified) Sat, 10/17/2026 - 10:52

In reply to by anticampist (not verified)

I had a feeling you'd say that.

You actually are NOT facing invasion today, because noone is going to. No power on Earth is going to launch a direct land invasion of your continent, especially it's North, because the cost benefit analysis does not come out in its favour. Maybe that will change someday but for now, nope, the US military is too strong and the people have too many guns.

They already did in the past, yes. I know this. As a European I am aware of the fact a few hundred years ago some of my ancestors got on the boats and some stayed. I can phone my cousin's there. I'm aware of how they got there. I'm aware of the violence.

Hell, I could get the bus to an old church, older than the state known as the USA, about an hour away. There are people commemorated there who left my country during or after the famine when they reckoned staying was death anyway so they might as well get on the ships and maybe they wouldn't die on the way. Worth the risk.

Some of them made it to Ellis Island and were told to fuck off, too many Irish already. In one case they snuck up north and tried to sneak in on what they thought was an empty shore. They were slaughtered by indigenous people.

In other cases, they got in and some did the slaughtering off indigenous people. I'm aware of how this played out. I'm not denying any of it.

If you want to argue that you already have been invaded by the USA/Canada etc, sure. I don't disagree. Every single white person there is a settler colonialist. The states all need abolished. You're welcome to pursue whatever your own political ambitions are in regards to this. You want to side with Russia. That's your choice. I disagree.

You must know that Russia contains a hell of a lot of little colonised/incorporated former states/territories that could itself Balkanise and split up? You know that there are hundreds of different ethnicities/micro groups there inside that might all go separatist in future, some of which already are? You know that the Russian empires forced conscription of these people is killing so many of them there are small ethnic groups at risk of extinction now? You can look all this up.

Even the category 'Russian' is a label that can fall apart and be, and is, rejected by a lot of people who currently officially/legally fall under it's reach.

The fact you were colonized is all irrelevant to what is happening in Ukraine and Europe today. Oh I know you'll say it isn't but it is. If anything, the Ukrainians are an example of a people who escaped and resisted Russia colonisation and are still trying to today.

If you're going to say the same thing over and over again - everyone in Europe is a: Nazi/liberal/NATO etc etc and we should just sit and die or do nothing when Russia invades us because that wouldn't be anarchist.

Because it's all about you, really? This situation happening on a different continent is about you?

It's not about you though.

I'm gonna be blunt, I don't think many people care or are thinking about you when Russian soldiers start to shell them, shoot civilians and steal their homes. Some might. But most aren't. If you don't want to support them that's your free choice.

If you want to sit there and say, over and over again, that anyone who faces what Ukrainians are facing is a Nazi for not siding with Russia because until we abolish every single state and military power we won't have anarchism - fine. This is an abstraction compared to the question of survival, which is the only thing on people's minds.

You think Russia is better. You don't want to oppose it's invasion because you are invaded and occupied yourself. You want Russia to win? I guess that'll teach us all a lesson about not going to the North American Continent a few centuries ago? I don't think this is fair. The Ukrainians are the ones that stayed. I am one of the Europeans that stayed. I haven't gotten on the boats or the planes to your continent like my ancestors did.

It's all about you man, except it's not. You can't even summon the empathy to see this one as not centering you as the subject of history. You're not Ukranian or European so you're not at the centre of this one. Sorry. You're a colonised person who is currently in a situation where you don't have the means to decolonise.

Again, all I have to say is that nobody here facing death is likely to see this in terms of what white people did to your continent.

There is this belief among some people that the Russians are really one big pure homogenous people. They're in reality more likely to break apart and start fighting than the whites of the USA and Canada are. Putin tries to keep a lid on the whole thing but he might not be able to forever.

You can expect to hear a lot more about anticolonial struggles against Russia from former Russian territories in future.

The LGBT people put in concentration camps by Putin's puppet regime in Chechnya, the many minorities being forced to die in the meat grinder - all of this is a separate situation from yours.

Do what you will and pursue whatever politics you will I guess. If we Europeans are going to be called NATO Nazis for resisting Russia well, we'll get over it.

What I would hope is that a greater understanding of this region can come about.

anonymous (not verified) Fri, 10/16/2026 - 16:28

In reply to by Bombsaway (not verified)

“why is there so much focus on azov?” idk, cause this is an anarchist website and anarchists are talking about or actually joining the ukrainian military, including azov? i don’t actually think russia is “better” for not having this type of ideologically and historically fascist unit in its military, and if anarchists were joining the russian military i’m sure we’d be talking about that too. right now your comment is just random whataboutism and name calling. why would a ‘tankie’ even bother posting here?

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
*
m
&
r
*
(
P
&
Enter the code without spaces.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.