From MTL Anarchist Bookfair
April 6, 2025
Hey everyone,
We're baa-aack! And we'd like to start by apologizing for our long absence. Communication is important, and we've left you hanging for a long time.
When we last checked in, we had announced that we were taking a year off to regroup as a collective and rethink the bookfair. Truth is, things were a little more complicated than that. From the outside, the 2023 Montreal Anarchist Bookfair seemed like a huge success. On the inside, our collective imploded.
That implosion involves many twists and turns, but in short, several of us had experienced harmful opinions and behaviors rooted in the logic of white superiority/supremacy as well as a lack of respect for the collective process by certain collective members. This resulted in misunderstandings, yelling matches, backstabbing, hurt feelings, broken friendships, and essentially, emotional and physical burnout. Some collective members did not abide by our collective decisions, shared confidential information beyond the collective, and spread misinformation that unnecessarily created bad feelings toward the bookfair. These actions undermined our ongoing efforts to make our organizing and the bookfair reflect a culture of care, accessibility, and alternative practices that at the same time challenge how the dominant culture shapes spaces.
It was important to the current collective to address problematic behaviors, and how they've repeatedly played out to make the bookfair less welcoming to marginalized people, in order to move forward. Moreover, it was deeply important to us not simply to push through and avoid tough conversations, as we had done in the past. Instead, we wanted to understand the underlying biases, forms of socialization, and structures that had shaped our internal dynamics, not to mention the bookfair itself, and as a consequence, too often reified the logic of white supremacy in our processes and project. By taking internal care rather than ignoring painful tensions, we strived to take the time to ensure the well-being and longevity of our collective, and in ways that would increasingly extend solidarity to all at the bookfair.
So in 2024, our time and funding were spent on a mediation process, which was skillfully guided by two POC facilitators from an outside organization.
Unfortunately, while the mediation process was helpful at opening up a respectful dialogue, the main issues did not get resolved, much less even addressed. In the end, the collective members from whom the rest of us had expected a certain level of accountability, left the mediation before completion and resigned from the collective.
This type of process takes a long time and a lot of energy, and it felt particularly demoralizing that our effort was essentially for naught; thus our need to take an extended break.
While we were trying to recover and plan ahead, an infographic appeared online, pronouncing our bookfair "dead," coupled with an illustration of someone giving us the finger. It felt like an attack. To make matters worse, we learned from a second, widely circulated announcement that a group had appropriated the bookfair, organizing it at the same place and same time, with only a change of name. Moreover, the only time these organizers reached out to us (and one of our sponsors, behind our backs) was in spring 2024, to request that we transfer our funds to them. Before we had a chance to start organizing the 2025 bookfair, this group once again announced that they would be holding an anarchist bookfair at our usual time and location.
As a result, instead of bringing you the bookfair that you have come to know and love this May, we will be preparing a two-day event over two weekends this fall. And we aim to again bring you the Montreal Anarchist Bookfair in May 2026.
The Montreal Anarchist Bookfair has always strived to be a place where anarchists and those curious about anarchism could come together to not only find educational materials but also experience care and community--something we've especially been expanding on the past several years to make the bookfair far more welcoming to far more types of ideas, practices, and people. We look forward to keeping that tradition alive.
Our current collective consists of BPOC as well as Jewish and Muslim anarchists. We hope to reach communities that have historically not been centered or given the space they deserve in the Montreal anarchist milieu. Stay tuned for what we hope will be an exciting return.
With love and rage,
Montreal Anarchist Bookfair Collective
Comments
"To make matters worse, we…
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 14:49
"To make matters worse, we learned from a second, widely circulated announcement that a group had appropriated the bookfair, organizing it at the same place and same time, with only a change of name. Moreover, the only time these organizers reached out to us (and one of our sponsors, behind our backs) was in spring 2024, to request that we transfer our funds to them. Before we had a chance to start organizing the 2025 bookfair, this group once again announced that they would be holding an anarchist bookfair at our usual time and location. "
Ok, so I don't think I know any of these people... but then again what are you, guise, the Central Committee!?
There was no IP on the Mtl ABF... and I doubt that, unless they're the cops or Maoists, there's people stupid enough to take over the bookfair just for the kicks or something. This event doesn't matter to 99,998% to the people living on this island, so why would anyone bother?
"While we were trying to recover and plan ahead, an infographic appeared online, pronouncing our bookfair "dead," coupled with an illustration of someone giving us the finger. It felt like an attack. "
Why aren't you sharing this content? What's with all these claims that aren't even substantiated?
I think the valuable lesson…
EmmaAintDead Mon, 04/07/2025 - 14:51
I think the valuable lesson here is that when idpol socialists try to drag you into a mediation process and publicly call you a nazi throughout, you CAN just walk away and do something better with your time that people will like more. You don't have to put up with it.
See y'all at constellation May 15th to 21st, info can be found here: https://constellationmtl.net/
Also everyone check out this…
EmmaAintDead Mon, 04/07/2025 - 14:55
In reply to I think the valuable lesson… by EmmaAintDead
Also everyone check out this fantastic response to the original post
wow, excellent response…
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 15:09
In reply to Also everyone check out this… by EmmaAintDead
wow, excellent response indeed. thanks for the link. also, glad to see that cedar's still kicking.
same here! huge respect to…
lumpy (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 15:17
In reply to wow, excellent response… by anon (not verified)
same here! huge respect to cedar, always seems to be the only one talkin any sense
I have no dog in this fight,…
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 15:13
In reply to Also everyone check out this… by EmmaAintDead
I have no dog in this fight, but I wouldn't really call this an "excellent" response. It's mostly just an inversion of the claims made by the original post. All of them unsubstantiated. I hope both book fairs are great, I'll be attending both.
uhhh ... nope? most of those…
lumpy (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 15:21
In reply to I have no dog in this fight,… by anon (not verified)
uhhh ... nope? most of those claims are quite easy to verify, in cedar's case
plus that assessment that most of the issue is a bad faith deployment of identity. it's quite clear if you read carefully and have any familiarity with the conflict
I don't have any familiarity…
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 16:16
In reply to uhhh ... nope? most of those… by lumpy (not verified)
I don't have any familiarity with the conflict, but since I visit this website I've been subjected to reading about it. I'm telling you how it appears to an outside observer. Both look like adolescents involved in a high school drama to me. I'll see you at one or the other book fairs, unless you've chosen to boycott one on principle?
and i'm respectfully…
lumpy (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 16:48
In reply to I don't have any familiarity… by anon (not verified)
and i'm respectfully suggesting to you that equivocating what these two groups are saying is quite strange
you've been "subjected to…
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 17:36
In reply to I don't have any familiarity… by anon (not verified)
you've been "subjected to reading about it"?! someone is forcing you to read this story? wow. maybe work on your agency?
Yes.
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 22:52
In reply to you've been "subjected to… by anon (not verified)
Yes.
you don't have to know…
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 16:18
In reply to I have no dog in this fight,… by anon (not verified)
you don't have to know anything about the conflict to know that a group acting like they own an event like a bookfair is pretty fucked up.
but have a good time straddling the fence at both.
"Straddling the fence" is a…
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 22:51
In reply to you don't have to know… by anon (not verified)
"Straddling the fence" is a rejection of the kind of binarism that produces this kind of shit in the first place. Eat shit, leftoid!
there are different kinds of…
anon (not verified) Tue, 04/08/2025 - 08:34
In reply to "Straddling the fence" is a… by anon (not verified)
there are different kinds of fence-straddling. the kind that happens at conflict that is as much personal as political is more commonly a sign that the straddler is afraid of the consequences of taking a stand than that they are of holding some transcendent perspective that is bigger than any of us.
i just find most fencing…
lumpy (not verified) Wed, 04/09/2025 - 10:13
In reply to there are different kinds of… by anon (not verified)
i just find most fencing will rip the crotch out of your pants or worse!
maybe they just suck at fence climbing and got stuck up there?
Thanks for sharing that-- I…
anon (not verified) Tue, 04/08/2025 - 06:59
In reply to Also everyone check out this… by EmmaAintDead
Thanks for sharing that-- I agree, it's a great response.
banning tarot lmfao
Good thing we don't need the…
The Ol' Millstone (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 15:43
Good thing we don't need the bookfair anymore 'cause we have the much better Constellation Anarchist Festival now!
https://constellationmtl.net/
Don't waste your time with…
anon (not verified) Mon, 04/07/2025 - 15:56
Don't waste your time with the MABC's bullshit, just read this instead: https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/rethinking-identity-safety-and-…
Just as a general wellness…
EmmaAintDead Mon, 04/07/2025 - 17:10
Just as a general wellness check, this statement got picked up by popular Instagram account @Cursed_Cancellations, which chronicles batshit crazy leftist callouts. How's things at home, Montreal Radical Booksale Cooperative?
Do you live entirely online?…
anon (not verified) Tue, 04/08/2025 - 08:49
In reply to Just as a general wellness… by EmmaAintDead
Do you live entirely online? I worry about you EAD. You approaching BEEP and KT territory with your terminally onlineness. Unless... *squints*
The spooks are back in town!
anon (not verified) Tue, 04/08/2025 - 07:24
Just when I was starting to miss that poser Marco as well as that professional poser FDD.
Well, not really after all... I'll be having a look at this year's Constellation instead, at least to see if my faith in anarchism can be restored in some way. The MABF was in the way for this.
wait. not clear. will tarot…
anon (not verified) Tue, 04/08/2025 - 08:41
wait. not clear. will tarot be banned? how about mohawks and "white" dreads? scented soap? will masks be required? i am asking seriously.
Whatever decree comes from…
anon (not verified) Tue, 04/08/2025 - 11:16
In reply to wait. not clear. will tarot… by anon (not verified)
Whatever decree comes from the Central Committee is eternal unless made void by its members. And you have no say, anarchist.
if you cancel something like…
anon (not verified) Wed, 04/09/2025 - 03:49
if you cancel something like the montreal anarchist bookfair you kinda gotta expect someone to pick it up
Add new comment